Sunday, May 10, 2009
God is in the Details
Wednesday, April 1, 2009
The Art of Argument
While Angie and I were camping last week, we had the 'pleasure' of listening to an argument in a nearby campsite.
- Because they're right - these folks fall into three categories:
a) Those that know they are right. Stay away from them. You aren't going to get anywhere, unless you're engaging in a Type 4 argument (having fun). In that case, party on!
b) Those that think they are right. You can actually have a productive argument with someone who thinks they are right.
c) Those that want to be right. Someone who's arguing about something they love (like family or religion) might fall in this category. You should ask yourself if this is an argument you're willing to win. The fallout may be too great. - Because you're wrong - These folks don't have a right answer. They just believe that you're wrong. You'd better have a great evidence, because you don't have any credibility with them on this issue.
- Because they're obstinate - They have a stance. They don't know if it's right. They don't care if you're wrong. They are not going to move.
- Because it's fun (for them) - I sometimes fall into this category. I like to argue for sport, with no attachment to outcome. And, I love to watch tightly strung people blow a gasket. If you're highly strung, you probably don't want to enter an argument with me or someone like me.
- Because they think the situation calls for a 'devils advocate' - It often helps to get an alternative point of view. Some people occupy this role strategically. Others do it as a way of life. Occasionally, the position is assigned to someone.
- Because it helps them think - Debating helps me think. I'll sometimes argue both sides of an issue within a half-hour. I'm not tied to any position yet.
Saturday, August 9, 2008
What is the Most Effective Educational Situation?
I'm reading The Adult Learner by Knowles, Holton and Swanson for my Masters degree class, and I came across psychologist Carl R. Rogers' five "basic hypotheses" of learning.
Number 5 is the one that resonated with me today:
"The educational situation which most effectively promotes significant learning is one in which threat to the self of the learner is reduced to a minimum, and differentiated perception of the field is facilitated."
Hmmm...
If "threat to the self of the learner is reduced" equals creating a safe environment and "differentiated perception of the field is facilitated" equals enabling a shift, then Carl R. Rogers suggested that coaching would be the most effective educational situation.
As much as I love classrooms, I agree that they are not optimal for creating a safe environment. Many people will not open up in a group setting, no matter what you do.
And it's hard to 'create the shift' in a room full of people, as well.
I'll be honest - I enjoy teaching and facilitating groups a lot more than I enjoy coaching.
Coaching is fun, but I learn more in group settings. I also feel that I make a bigger impact in groups.
I'll have to think about this quote and observe the dynamics in both settings before I decide whether I agree or not...
What do you think?
Monday, August 4, 2008
What are the Six Thinking Hats?
Today marked the start of our summer workshops for the learning center and human resource departments.
I've organized two weeks of teaching new tools and practicing old ones. We kicked off today with Six Thinking Hats.
If you're not familiar with this thinking framework, you should check it out immediately. I never get tired of singing its' praises.
Here's a google search for 'six thinking hats pdf'. This will give you plenty of info to choose from. Or you can order Edward de Bono's book from Amazon.
The class is excellent. I enjoy putting strong tools into the hands of people who need them.
We had a good session today, with a lot of practice exercises. I'm looking forward to seeing it rolled out. It's amazing to see the shift from an exercise done without the Six Thinking Hats, to one done with them.
The basic concept is that debate results in an 'arm-wrestling' mentality that reduces any possibility of finding the best answer through synthesis. Any election shows how true this proposition is.
Instead, Six Thinking Hats proposes that we work through the six types of thinking together. The six types are:
- Blue/Process,
- White/Information,
- Red/Emotion,
- Yellow/Positive,
- Red/Negative,
- Green/Creative
If you think your group would benefit from reduced debate, better ideas, and more engaged participation, then take a look at Six Thinking Hats.